FaveCard
Start for free

Benchmark

State of Loyalty 2026: how often card members come back

In FaveCard's records across 3,287 small businesses, 40% of customers who joined a loyalty card came back on another day within 60 days.

Updated 19 November 2026 · Next update February 2027

40%

Share of loyalty card joiners at small businesses who came back on a different day within 60 days.

In FaveCard's records of 3,287 small businesses (not a survey), 40% of customers getting their first stamp between 25 May and 22 August 2026 came back for another stamp on a different day within 60 days (17,088 of 42,726). Of those who came back, half did so within 14 days. The share was 44% in the United States and 44% in Europe.

Sample
42,726 customers joining (first stamp)
Businesses
3,287 small local businesses
Timespan
First stamps between 25 May and 22 August 2026, followed for 60 days

FaveCard’s first State of Loyalty report comes from FaveCard’s own records of stamps, cards and rewards at small local businesses, not from a survey. Following FaveCard’s loyalty card completion rate benchmark from May 2026, the report shows how often card members come back to the counter, not that the card caused their visits. Anyone may quote and reuse the numbers under CC BY 4.0 with a link to this page.

What share of customers who join a local loyalty card come back?

Across 3,287 small local businesses in FaveCard’s records, 40% of customers who got their first stamp between 25 May and 22 August 2026 came back for another stamp on a different day within 60 days (17,088 of 42,726 customers).

Customers who came back within 60 days, by region

Customers whose first stamp at a business fell between 25 May and 22 August 2026, with each customer followed for 60 days ending no later than 21 October 2026.

Where Came back within 60 days Joined (first stamp) Businesses Share who came back
All 17,088 42,726 3,287 40%
United States 1,784 4,087 475 44%
Europe 6,176 14,170 729 44%

“Came back” means another stamp on a different day, not on the day of joining. Everyone is counted, including customers at businesses that later stopped using FaveCard; without them the share is 44%. The likely range of the overall share is 37% to 42%. The United States and Europe do not add up to all businesses: other countries, and businesses with no country in their profile, count only in the “All” row.

Because a customer can visit without collecting a stamp, a stamp is not every visit, and real visits are at least as many.

How long does it usually take a new customer to come back?

In FaveCard’s records, half of the loyalty card joiners who came back within 60 days returned for another stamp within 14 days. The count covers customers who got their first stamp at a small local business between 25 May and 22 August 2026, each followed for 60 days.

What is a good customer retention rate for a small business like a café, a salon or a shop?

At the middle business among 450 local businesses in FaveCard’s records (with at least 20 card joiners between 25 May and 22 August 2026), 44% of joiners came back within 60 days. Shares were under 29% in the bottom quarter of businesses and over 59% in the top quarter. All kinds of local businesses are grouped together rather than split by trade.

Share of card joiners coming back within 60 days, by business quartile

450 businesses with at least 20 customers joining between 25 May and 22 August 2026, each followed for 60 days across all local trades combined.

Where a business stands Share of card joiners who came back within 60 days
Bottom quarter of businesses under 29%
The middle business (median) 44%
Top quarter of businesses over 59%

Here every business counts once, however many customers it has; in the overall lead number every customer counts once, which is why the middle business can differ from the overall share. Businesses with fewer than 20 customers joining in the window are left out because one or two customers would swing their share.

To compare your own business, take the customers who got their first stamp in one month and count how many got another stamp on a different day within the next 60 days. Dividing returning customers by everyone who joined in that month puts your business on the same scale as the quartiles here.

Are digital loyalty cards saved in Apple Wallet, Google Wallet or the browser?

In FaveCard’s records of loyalty cards created between 16 August and 13 November 2026, two in three cards created on an iPhone were added to Apple Wallet, and two in five cards created on an Android phone were saved to Google Wallet. All remaining cards are opened as a page in the phone’s browser.

Loyalty cards saved to a phone wallet, by phone type

Loyalty cards created between 16 August and 13 November 2026. The window runs past 21 October 2026 because it counts cards, not customers.

Phone Cards created Saved to the wallet Share in the wallet
iPhone (Apple Wallet) 59,789 39,335 two in three
Android (Google Wallet) 30,632 11,864 two in five

Counts cover cards, not customers: one customer can hold two cards. Cards not saved in a wallet open as a page in the phone's browser. Almost no cards are created on a computer.

For a business choosing a digital card, the card needs to work in both phone wallets and in the browser, because a real share of cards stays in the browser. As an example, a FaveCard loyalty card works in Apple Wallet, Google Wallet and the browser.

On which days do regulars visit small local businesses most?

At the typical local business, the quietest open day of the week gets about half the visits of its busiest day (250+ businesses with at least 10 visits a week). Measured by the typical business’s share of a week’s visits across 850+ businesses, Monday has the fewest visits of Monday to Friday and Friday has the most; Sunday has fewer still, because many businesses are closed on Sundays. This report covers days, not times of day, counting visits as stamps in FaveCard’s records between 22 August and 13 November 2026.

Quietest and busiest days of the week

From stamps recorded between 22 August and 13 November 2026. The open-day comparison covers 250+ businesses with at least 10 visits a week and counts only days a business is open; the days of the week cover 850+ businesses, using the typical business's share of a week's visits.

Measure Result
Quietest open day, compared with the busiest (typical business) about half
Fewest visits (typical business's share of a week's visits) Sunday (many closed); Monday from Monday to Friday
Most visits (typical business's share of a week's visits) Friday
Businesses 250+ (open-day comparison); 850+ (days of the week)

Visits are counted as stamps, and a stamp is not every visit. The window runs past 21 October 2026 because it counts visits rather than customers.

What share of loyalty card members reach a reward within 90 days?

In FaveCard’s records of customers who got their first stamp between 25 April and 23 July 2026, 18% redeemed a reward at a later visit within 90 days (6,415 of 36,057 customers). Over the same 90 days, 14% filled their whole card (3,248 of 23,704), or about one in seven. Rewards redeemed and cards filled on the day of joining are left out.

Rewards redeemed and whole cards filled within 90 days

Customers whose first stamp fell between 25 April and 23 July 2026, with each customer followed for 90 days ending no later than 21 October 2026.

Within 90 days of joining Customers Out of Share
Redeemed a reward at a later visit 6,415 36,057 18%
Filled the whole card 3,248 23,704 14%

Rewards redeemed on the day of joining are left out (for example when stamps are carried over from a paper card). Cards filled on the day of joining are left out too. The reward share counts every customer who joined (36,057), while the whole-card share counts only customers whose card size is known (23,704), because card size is recorded only since 1 October 2026.

FaveCard’s May 2026 loyalty card completion rate benchmark measured something different. Because both the unit and the sample differ, the two numbers should not be compared directly.

Why there are no separate numbers for the UK or Germany

In each of the UK and Germany, one business would weigh too much in a separate number, so the page gives one combined number for Europe (44% coming back within 60 days). Europe is not dominated by one country: the UK is the largest part, making up nearly a third of Europe’s customers in this data (customers who joined, not businesses), followed by France and Spain, while Germany is a small part.

Planning around a quiet day in your week

An owner can look over their own week, spot which open day is quietest at the counter and plan around it, whether by adjusting staff hours or putting together an offer for regulars. As an example, FaveCard coupons can be set to work only on the days and hours you choose.

Methodology

Click to expand

Sources

All numbers come from FaveCard's own records of stamps, cards and rewards at small local businesses that use FaveCard, not from a survey. Every figure is aggregated and anonymised, and no individual business or customer is named. Earlier benchmark work appears in FaveCard (2026), Loyalty Card Completion Rate Benchmark (May 2026).

Filter

Every number rests on at least 50 customers and 20 businesses, and no single business makes up more than 10% of any number. Windows that follow customers over time, covering returns and rewards, end on 21 October 2026 because the way FaveCard records customers changed on 22 October 2026. Counts of cards and visits do not depend on that change and run later. Each table gives its own window.

Definitions

“Joined” means a customer's first stamp on a business's card, and “came back” means another stamp on a different day. A “reward” is a reward redeemed at a later visit, not on the day of joining. A “card” means one card at one business, and one customer can hold two cards. A business's “quietest open day” is the day of the week with the fewest visits among the days that business is open.

Known biases

A stamp is not every visit, because a customer can visit without getting a stamp, so real visits are at least as many as the stamp counts recorded here. These numbers show how often card members come back, not that the card, a reward or FaveCard caused those visits. Businesses that use FaveCard are not a random sample of all local businesses. Businesses with no country in their profile count only in the overall numbers.

How to cite

If you are referencing this benchmark in an article, deck, or study, use the format below. We re-run the analysis quarterly.

FaveCard (2026). State of Loyalty 2026: how often card members come back. Aggregate analysis of FaveCard's records of stamps, cards and rewards at small local businesses. Retrieved from https://www.favecard.co/en/benchmarks/state-of-loyalty-2026/

Updated: 19 November 2026 Next update: 15 February 2027
12 min read